Surprisingly, an anxious client can leave a session more frightened than when they arrived, because of how carefully we listened.
Clients and colleagues have described a pattern to me that I’d put, as a composite, like this: “I’m scared and I don’t know what to do. And I think my therapist is scared and doesn’t know what to do either. They just keep repeating back what I’ve said.”
With anxiety, I think we need to be proactive and confident. The client needs to borrow a nervous system calmer than their own: co-regulation. Reflection on its own doesn’t supply that.
Here is the order I work in.
First, bring their arousal down, early, in the room: feet on the floor, feel the chair beneath you, breathe in for 3 and out for 6. I say what we are doing and why: a secure base from which to feel difficult feelings, and breathing to help regulate them. A clear rationale is containing in itself.
Second, validate and affirm. When shame about the fear arrives, help them stay with the shame state until it passes. With repeated practice of regulating the shame state, each occurrence gradually reduces in intensity and duration. It helps if we’ve practised on ourselves, so we know.
Third, help them find what the fear may be covering. Two patterns from emotion-focused therapy are worth knowing:
Secondary reactive fear. A primary adaptive feeling, say anger at a values violation, followed by fear of what that anger might require of them.
Maladaptive fear. Whatever the primary feeling, it comes out as fear, the way some people turn everything into anger.
As their arousal settles and their body awareness improves, I help them name what they feel. When they can’t, I offer a word from empathic attunement and check it with them. Then we focus inward. How come you feel this way? And what does that feeling need? Anger often needs our boundaries respected. Sadness needs comfort for a loss.
There is some research company here. In a feasibility trial in Irish primary care, emotion-focused therapy for generalised anxiety, which works with the painful feelings clients avoid, including shame, produced large improvements that held at six months. 58 clients, and a feasibility study, not a definitive trial.
The conditions we create for our clients matter.
- Confidence is not certainty. Containing means being steady and providing co-regulation, not pretending to know.
- Pacing belongs to the client.
- A calm voice must not become a way of managing our own anxiety.
- Panic, OCD and PTSD have specific treatments, and some clients need them.
- Coaches need to know where their remit ends.
A question for supervision: “When your client was most frightened, what did you do with your own uncertainty?”
The sequence is my clinical practice, not a tested protocol.
The free worksheet that goes with this is What Else Is Under the Fear?, which includes a page of reflective questions for therapists, coaches and supervisors.
Reference
Timulak, L., Keogh, D., Chigwedere, C., Wilson, C., Ward, F., Hevey, D., Griffin, P., Jacobs, L., Hughes, S., Vaughan, C., Beckham, K., & Mahon, S. (2022). A comparison of emotion-focused therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy in the treatment of generalized anxiety disorder: Results of a feasibility randomized controlled trial. Psychotherapy, 59(1), 84–95. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000427
What does your anxious client borrow from you?